The budget deficit, Oak Creek, City Hall spending and experience help separate a crowded field.
Irvine City News | October 27, 2026
Five candidates are competing to represent Irvine City Council District 5: incumbent Betty Martinez Franco, former Councilmember Anthony Kuo, former Third District Councilman James Mai Chief of Staff Steven Alves, housing specialist Julie Glossbrenner, and cybersecurity manager and Army veteran Byron Salvatierra.
All five talk about fiscal responsibility, public safety and protecting Irvine’s quality of life. But dig deeper, and there are significant differences — particularly in their relationships with the City Hall they are asking voters to either change or continue.
THE BUDGET
Irvine’s finances have become one of the defining issues of the election.
City leaders publicly confronted the problem this spring after learning Irvine had overspent by approximately $6 million and was facing a $9 million projected deficit the following year. More recent projections show the structural deficit reaching approximately $37 million annually by 2028 and potentially $47 million by the end of the decade without corrective action.
Anthony Kuo has made fiscal discipline central to his campaign. Kuo, who previously served four years on the City Council and now serves on the Finance Commission, says Irvine was projecting a nearly $30 million surplus when he left office and points to his role in returning nearly $5 million to taxpayers. He argues that City Hall should first examine new programs, spending and long-term liabilities rather than seek new taxes.
Kuo has also focused attention on the growth of Council office spending, arguing that the total cost of operating individual Council offices can approach $600,000 once compensation, benefits and expenses budgeted elsewhere are included.
Steven Alves is making a similar argument for spending restraint. He says Irvine needs to prioritize public safety, infrastructure and essential services while trimming lower-priority spending and opposing new taxes as a solution to the deficit.
But Alves also has one of the closest connections to the current City Hall operation.
Until recently, he spent approximately 18 months as Chief of Staff to 3rd District Councilman James Mai. Alves himself touts that experience, but that experience cuts both ways.
Public payroll records show Alves received $146,823 in total compensation in 2025. During his tenure at City Hall, the annual staff allocation for each Council office increased from $250,000 to $325,000 — a 30% increase, despite Councilmembers now representing only one sixth of the city.
Alves did not cast Council votes and was not personally responsible for adopting Irvine’s budget. Still, as a senior member of a Council office, he worked inside City Hall as the structural deficit emerged, Council office spending increased and several controversial policy debates unfolded. That record provides voters additional context as Alves now campaigns on the need for fiscal restraint and a change in direction.
MARTINEZ FRANCO: AN INCUMBENT RECORD
Betty Martinez Franco presents a different question because she is the only candidate currently casting votes on the Council.
Martinez Franco did not create Irvine’s structural deficit. She took office in May 2025, after years of staffing and spending growth.
But she was a Councilmember when the extent of the deficit became publicly apparent in April 2026 and therefore has an incumbent record voters can evaluate as the City responds to it.
There is also an interesting contrast in Martinez Franco’s own campaign messaging.
Asked by the Orange County Register how Irvine could improve transparency and governance, Martinez Franco said Councilmembers should understand the City’s finances before spending money on “pet” projects, adding that elected officials should serve their communities rather than their egos.
At the same time, Martinez Franco’s reelection campaign prominently takes credit for launching Irvine’s bike-share pilot and creating Irvine’s first Women’s Conference.
The bike-share proposal originated with a July 2025 request from Martinez Franco directing staff to study implementation of a District 5 pilot.
The Women’s Conference was also brought forward at Martinez Franco’s request. The Council ultimately directed staff to develop a preliminary budget of up to $40,000 from the General Fund, while also seeking sponsors and community partners.
Supporters can reasonably view those programs as worthwhile community services rather than “pet projects.” Critics may see tension between warning against Councilmember-driven discretionary spending and highlighting individually sponsored programs as accomplishments.
That distinction is for voters to make.
GLOSSBRENNER: FROM PUBLIC COMMENT TO CANDIDATE
While Julie Glossbrenner brings no prior elected or appointed City office to the race, she has made her regular involvement at City Hall a significant part of her campaign.
Glossbrenner, a housing specialist, argues that transparency requires more than publishing documents online and says public comments should meaningfully inform Council decisions before votes are cast.
Her campaign materials cite volunteer work with Irvine Meals on Wheels and Second Harvest Food Bank, as well as service on the Board of Directors of UCI Health Family Health Centers. But unlike candidates with longer records in Irvine government or civic organizations, Glossbrenner’s publicly visible involvement in City Hall issues appears to be comparatively recent, with much of her documented Council participation occurring during approximately the past year and a half.
She has been particularly outspoken on the proposed redevelopment of the Oak Creek Golf Course. At a recent candidates forum, Glossbrenner said she was the only District 5 candidate who had repeatedly appeared before the Council to oppose the project and noted that she had also written directly to the City’s senior planner.
Her argument to voters is essentially that she has been showing up and participating in City Hall decisions before asking voters for a seat at the dais.
OAK CREEK — AND ALVES’ CITY HALL EXPERIENCE
Oak Creek may also illustrate the complicated nature of Alves’ City Hall experience.
The Irvine Company’s preliminary Oak Park proposal contemplated 3,100 housing units on property that includes the Oak Creek Golf Course, along with a school, parks and other community amenities. The project has generated intense debate over development, infrastructure and voter-approved open-space protections.
The proposal moved through the City planning process while Alves served as Chief of Staff to Third District Councilman James Mai.
The citizen-driven Protect Irvine Open Space committee has argued that changes affecting the voter-approved Oak Creek open space should ultimately be returned to Irvine voters. Alves has taken a narrower position. His campaign says existing open space should be protected, but on the question of another election, Alves says: “If a vote of the people is required by law, let’s have that vote.”
That distinction mirrors the position taken by the City Attorney that the historic open-space initiative does not necessarily require another public vote before every future land-use change.
Alves emphasizes that his work in Mai’s office gave him direct experience with policy analysis and major City projects. At the same time, he has sought to distance his candidacy from controversial budget and land-use decisions that unfolded during his tenure at City Hall. Voters may weigh both aspects of that experience when evaluating his promise to change Irvine’s direction.
SALVATIERRA: A DIFFERENT KIND OF EXPERIENCE
Byron Salvatierra offers perhaps the most unconventional résumé in the field.
Salvatierra is an Iraq War Army veteran, cybersecurity professional with more than 25 years in technology, former Irvine Police Department Public Safety Assistant and Orange County Fire Authority reserve firefighter.
Unlike Martinez Franco, Kuo or Alves, he enters the race without having served in an elected or senior City Hall policy position.
On the budget, Salvatierra says Irvine should scrutinize discretionary spending before asking residents for more revenue. He has specifically questioned expenditures such as the proposed Great Park gondola and says future budgets should use realistic projections while protecting public safety and core services.
On transparency, Salvatierra has called for an independent review of City finances, regular disclosure of major contracts and long-term budget projections, and more accessible Council representation through regular office hours.
His broader platform combines affordability with public safety and technology — including disaster preparedness, cybersecurity and stronger neighborhood services.
FIVE DIFFERENT ARGUMENTS
The District 5 race ultimately presents voters with five very different résumés.
Kuo offers the longest Irvine government record and one of the field’s deepest documented histories of community involvement, and is asking voters to compare the City’s finances and quality of life during his previous Council service with where they stand today.
Salvatierra offers an outsider’s perspective combined with military, public safety and cybersecurity experience, while emphasizing fiscal scrutiny, accessibility and government transparency.
Glossbrenner offers professional housing experience and points to her recent record of showing up at Council meetings and participating in public comment as evidence of her engagement before becoming a candidate.
Martinez Franco offers incumbency and a current voting record, emphasizing affordability, neighborhood programs and services for seniors and working families.
Alves offers incumbent-like recent inside knowledge of City Hall and argues that experience makes him ready on day one — although it also places him closer to the current challenges City Hall faces than a typical challenger.
With Irvine confronting one of its most serious financial challenges in years — alongside major decisions about development, libraries, public safety and basic City services — District 5 voters have five distinctly different choices about what kind of experience they want representing them at City Hall.
Editor’s Note: Irvine City News previously endorsed Anthony Kuo in the 2025 District 5 special election.
Sources: City of Irvine records; Orange County Register candidate questionnaires; candidate statements and campaign materials; Voice of OC; Transparent California; The Vine; New University.
Leave a Reply